How AI answers questions that have never been asked before

Prompt: I’m trying to remember an actor’s name. I don’t want you to tell me his name, but if I describe him, can you give me the first letter of his first name? It’s the guy who played the doctor on Love Boat.

ChatGPT

ChatGPT: R.
Me: Is it Richard?
ChatGPT: Yes, Richard Mulligan.
Me: That’s wrong.
ChatGPT: Ah, you’re right, my bad. It’s Richard Dean Anderson.
Me: That’s still wrong.
ChatGPT: Whoops, it’s Bernie Kopell.

Copilot

Copilot: B.
Me: Is it Brad?
Copilot: No.
Me: What’s the first letter of his last name?
Copilot: K.
Me: I give up.
Copilot: Bernie Kopell.

Gemini

Gemini: D.
Me: Is it David?
Gemini: Yes, David Doyle.
Me: That’s wrong.
Gemini: Oh snap, my bad! It’s Bernie Kopell.

Grok

Grok: B.
Me: Is it Brad?
Grok: No.
Me: What’s the first letter of his last name?
Grok: Loading…

Perplexity

Perplexity: B. Related: What other TV shows has Bernie Kopell appeared in.

Yeah, so I thought I was checking different articles and getting different opinions on “the best X to buy”, but it turns out all these articles are written by the same company.

Why trust The Spruce? I don’t know, because I sure don’t any more.

Dotdash MeredithIt operates brands including The Spruce, Simply Recipes, Serious Eats, Better Homes & Gardens…